Jul 222010

Only one place to start today, and that is with the news that Eduardo has left Arsenal to join Shakhtar Donetsk for a fee believed to be around the £6m mark. That he would leave has been likely for the last six months, but a move to the Ukraine suggests that his stock has fallen considerably since those early days at the Emirates, where he was developing into one of the deadliest finishers in the Premiership.

Sadly, Eduardo never fully recovered from that fateful day at St Andrews, his leg shattered by an enforcer tackle from ‘not that kind of player’ Martin Taylor. That kind of injury and a year out of the game would test anyone, but while he appeared to recover physically, he was hindered by mental scars that removed the clinical finishing his game relied on. His instincts were still good, his first touch was immaculate, but in front of goal his assurance had gone.

And in one of the most physical leagues in the world, I haven’t seen him compete in a 50/50 challenge in the year and a half he’s been back. Can you blame him?

We will never know the heights Eduardo could have reached. Perhaps he would have been a star, perhaps a useful squad player who could turn games late on. One thing is for certain – the ‘they don’t like it up ’em’ brigade have claimed a victim today, removing another talent from the English game. How many more will follow?

Much as Eduardo has always been a fan favourite, and although he was noticeably touched by the reception he received on his return, I wouldn’t blame him if he never looked back. His treatment during his three years in England has been appalling – that challenge, the Villa fans who taunted him with ‘you’ve only got one leg’, and of course the diving storm from last season’s Champions League qualifier which saw UEFA attempt to ban him for an offence replicated a hundred times the same week.

I don’t know any right-minded person who doesn’t wish him well. Perhaps a fresh start and regular football will help him re-establish his poise in front of goal, and I hope his recovery is completed over the next year or so.

Financially, it is no bad deal – £6m is a sizable fee for someone whose future is unknown, and is not far off the amount he cost in the first place.

Elsewhere, pre-season has started, and while the internet age allows us to watch these warm-up games in full rather than scouring newspapers for the result, drawing conclusions from them can be dangerous, particularly when focusing on the negative. For example, our defending in today’s 3-0 win against Sturm Graz was exceptionally wobbly at times, but nothing more can be expected when holidays have only just ended and fitness levels are low.

That said, it is a chance for younger players to stake their claim for first team action in the weeks ahead, and Jack Wilshere, Jay Emmanuel-Thomas and Jay Simpson have all caught the eye in the last week. Of the three, Wilshere is closest to featuring, especially with Joe Cole moving to Liverpool for the money the Champions League a fresh start. JET and Simpson still have much to prove.

Of the new signings, Chamakh looks powerful, Koscielny the complete opposite (that boy needs to bulk up, and fast), and of the old guard, Nasri shone tonight while Arshavin oozed class against Barnet but needs to raise his fitness levels. In goal, Almunia is ‘ill’, which is giving chances to everyone else, but it is difficult to take those chances when the opposition doesn’t threaten.

What these friendlies are showing us is the depth of attacking talent at our disposal – some very good players are not going to make it at Arsenal due to the levels of competition. It is the other end of the pitch that causes all the problems, and I suspect another signing will be made in defence before the season begins.

And that is it for tonight, except to wish Eduardo well with Shakhtar Donetsk. Good luck, fella.

  17 Responses to “Eduardo gets the move he needs + early pre-season thoughts”

  1. Top Top Post mate.

    Agree on all the post’s, only thing i can add is All the best to Eduardo, I Dont think ive felt this bad over somebody leaving since Henry/Viera/Pires ect…

    Shame, A real shame.

    One thing or two about pre-season, i think two young defenders has caught the eye of many, Frimpong was brilliant in the first half at Barnet and got around against Graz. Looks a real powerhouse.
    And the second, H.Nordtviet.. at right back…. Looked brilliant tonight, movement, passing, tackling, heading, looked really solid tonight, And equally
    against barnet.


    • Thanks.

      I watched Nordtveit tonight, and like you I was impressed. It’ll be interesting to see where he fits in.

      • Ship him out on loan to a Championship/PL club, miles away from beeing ready for Arsenal first team action. This was Sturm Graz and I never felt comfortable with him(or defense in general)

        • He looked better than Kos. I’d say he’s ready to be 4th/5th choice, plus he’s got DM experience and can be back-up there too.

          • Koscielny is very raw but may improve quickly – I assume he’s ahead of Nordtveit in the order. Wouldn’t be surprised if the Norwegian went on loan again, depends on whether we make another defensive signing.

    • Norveidt is playing now because Sagna and Eboué got back late to training for being in the World Cup.

      We might see him in the Carling Cup side at RB and back up for CB.

  2. Where is denilson!?

  3. deneilson and nikki b ahve a groin injury…..
    i hope sum one develops into a good back up for song….
    if not we need to get one…..

    1 more cb is a must…

  4. Wenger should stop giving number 9 shirt to our strikers.
    List of Arsenal No.9:
    Francis Jeffers
    Davor Suker
    Paul Merson (switched from No.10 due to Bergkamp arrival)
    See the curse there?

  5. Extremely worried about this new Koscielny guy. Heard bad things before he arrived for an astronomical fee, and hearing even worse things now about the pint sized, slender built frenchman. I can guarantee you right now that we will not win a trophy this year again if we don’t sign another quality defender/ goalkeeper or that particular area (GK) drastically improves. I would much rather Mark Scwarczer come in for a season, than go through more hurling remotes and swearing when flippy (almunie) and flappy (fabianski) stand in goal.

    • I’m convinced Wenger is still in the market for a stopgap keeper and a central defender. Koscielny is well aware that he needs to bulk out – he has already said so, and from what I hear he is an excellent technician.

      He will probably be phased in later in the season once his physicality has improved – at the moment the pairing is Vermaelen/Djourou but like you I’d want another option in there.

      • I Dont know. I think he looks a great defender, He gets tight to his man, reads the game well.
        But like you all say, He needs to bulk out because players like Drogba,Heskey (Yes even heskey) will take him out.

        And i like Djourou a lot, Think hes matured since hes been out.
        Problem is, Can he stay fit.

        Cant wait for the Liverpool game to see who the NO.1 is and the Central pairing is.

  6. The 4-3-3 system doesn’t suit Eduardo either. He’s definitely better as a second striker in a 4-4-2.

    Did Jay Simpson fly to Austia?
    If not, he will not get into the first team.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.